South Jersey Legal Ethics Lawyers – Playboy Enterprises Legal Malpractice Suit


Playboy Enterprises has been hit with a six million dollar jury verdict in Zulfer v. Playboy Enterprises, Inc., a landmark SOX whistleblower case. The company is currently suing its former defense counsel, Sheppard Mullin, for his part in the case, claiming Mullin should have urged the company to settle as opposed to trying the case. The jury award is the largest amount ever awarded in a SOX case.

Catherine Zulfer, formerly Playboy’s Controller, testified that her employment was terminated because she refused to accumulate one million dollars in discretionary bonuses for executives before they had been approved by Playboy’s Board. The jury ruled in Zulfer’s favor, saying that Zulfer’s termination for her protected reports under SOX was an unlawful retaliation. In addition, by terminating Zulfer’s employment, Playboy violated public policy under California law. Playboy argued that a whistleblower complaint about anticipated conduct is not protected under SOX.

Playboy’s suit against Mullin claims that the defense counsel was unrealistically optimistic about the likelihood of a successful outcome. If the company had settled out of court, Playboy Enterprises could have saved several million dollars. Instead, the jury awarded six million dollars to Zulfer, which exceeded the five million dollars cap on Playboy’s liability insurance policy.

The jury took less than two hours to rule in favor of Catherine Zulfer. Ultimately, Playboy’s total bill, with punitive damages and attorney fees, came to $7.6 million. According to Playboy, Mullin urged the company to go to trial because he felt confident that based on mock jury trials that were conducted in preparation for the case Playboy had a 75% chance of winning the case.

As the defendant in a legal malpractice case , it is crucial that you obtain objective representation with an experienced South Jersey legal ethics lawyer. The outcome of an ethics malpractice case can have serious personal and professional repercussions. It is important that you do not attempt to handle the ethics defense yourself. Our dedicated team of South Jersey legal ethics lawyers at the Law Offices of Agre & St. John will fight for your interests and ensure that your license and reputation are protected.

Our offices are conveniently located in Haddonfield, New Jersey and we represent lawyers and law firms who are facing legal ethics violations in South Jersey , including Burlington County, Camden County, Gloucester County, Salem County and Cumberland County. To set up a consultation with one of our qualified South Jersey ethics lawyers , call us at 856-454-8674 or contact us online.

Schedule Your Criminal Defense Case Evaluation

Provide the information below or call us at:


100% Secure. We respect your privacy.

See here.

firm logo
handcuff icon

Criminal Defense

building icon

Federal Crimes

shield icon


gavel icon

Drug Crimes

person icon

Sex Crimes

scale icon

Weapons Offenses

Client Reviews

  • "The best guys for representation you could ever want!"

    "Excellent advice and direction. Knowledgeable of all options. Prepares you for every step of your case, even when you aren't aware. If you find them, stop looking and just call Chris or Bob. Their bios speak for themselves. They are so friendly and care about you and your case!!"

  • "I highly recommend Robert Agre to anyone in need of a criminal attorney"

    "Robert Agre told me what to expect each step of my case. He earned my trust with his knowledge of criminal law, ability to explain the process, and open communication. I was most impressed by his quick response time to my many questions throughout the process. I am grateful that I found him and appreciate everything he did for me. "

  • "I recommend Mr. St. John to any individual seeking counsel"

    "Mr. St. John has not only proficiently and tenaciously defended me each time it was necessary, he has gone above and beyond. With Mr. St. John, I never felt as though I was a number, a file, or merely a client. His professionalism, reputation, and rapport in the field are apparent without the need for words. I have and will continue to trust him without hesitation, despite the underlying fear brought about by criminal charges. Chris, THANK YOU for the compassion and kindness you possess, which parallel the dedication you have to individuals such as myself."

See all client reviews
firm logo

Get A 100% Free Case Evaluation From A Top-Rated Criminal Defense Attorney

Call: 856-454-8674 or Schedule Consultation

Meet your team

Robert N. Agre Christopher St. John Tess Berkowitz Shirley Genay Shirley Genay